Protesters Clash Outside Pan Am Hearing

14A Protesters

A crowd protesting Elmhurst’s Pan Am homeless
shelter gathered Monday outside a public hearing
on the shelter.

Staff Writer

Cries of “get a job,” “pay your rent” and “get out” rang across Goldsmith Street in Elmhurst Monday night, as protesters of the Pan American homeless shelter met counter-protesters from the shelter.

Thirty-six families were moved into the Pan American hotel in early June, to the surprise of the community and elected officials. Ninety now live there. The DHS had initially declared the site unsuitable, but then granted Samaritan Village an emergency decree to open the shelter.

The community has since been vocal in challenging the City’s decision to quietly put a shelter in an area already burdened with some of the most overcrowded hospitals and schools in New York.

Hundreds of Elmhurst residents calling for the shelter to be shut down gathered on the lawn outside the Elks Lodge in the early evening, where inside, Community Board 4 was holding a public hearing on the shelter with elected officials, community members and representatives from the Dept. of Homeless Services and Samaritan Village, which runs the shelter.

The protesters faced a group of counter-protesters from the shelter, booing and shouting. One child waved a sign reading “2, 4, 6, 8, who do we NOT appreciate? Hobos, hobos!” The counter-protest group, which grew in about an hour from eight individuals to roughly two dozen, consisted mostly of shelter residents with children, alongside some community advocates. Michael West lives in the Pan American shelter with his wife Lale West and five-month-old son.

“She’s working, I’m working, we’re doing what we got to do to get the money up so we can get our apartment,” West said. “Everybody’s working to get out right now.” DHS statistics indicate that the number of people in homeless shelters has risen steadily since 2012. According to Lorraine Stephens, first deputy commissioner of the DHS, there are currently 54,000 individuals in City shelters, 11,000 of which are families. Stephens called homelessness a City-wide crisis and said the DHS is not sure what is causing it.

Some of the shelter protesters’ sentiments were echoed during the hearing inside. One speaker who did not identify herself said, “long-term residents of Elmhurst, Queens have worked long hours and we’re motivated to have a roof over our heads” while others get a “free ride” and “free pass.” Resident Regina Quiet said she has seen people skulking outside and followed them to the shelter. “Our crime has already started going up, you have no control over them,” she said. “Half those people need to get up off their fat butts and get a job.”

According to Deputy Inspector Ronald Leyson, the 110th precinct has seen no uptick in crime that it can attribute to the shelter, and does not expect to. Odette Lupis came to the hearing from Astoria to speak out for the shelter’s residents.  “I’m looking for work, and as everybody who’s looking for work knows, you don’t find it when you need it. So I could be your next homeless person,” she said.

After the hearing, Councilman Daniel Dromm (D-Jackson Heights) said that “many of those questions and the characterizations of the people [in the shelter] that some of the people had here tonight, those questions could have been answered had [DHS and Samaritan Village] notified the community in advance.” The number that they’re asking to put in here, without any additional services to the community, is unacceptable,” Dromm added.

Resident Jenny Shao distinguished between laying fault on the residents of the shelter and on the DHS and Samaritan Village. “Homeless people, we do need to support them. But is putting a shelter in Pan Am the right support that they need?” Show asked. “I work at a school where I don’t even have money to buy textbooks. So what are you doing for our schools? You want the children to go to our schools, and I want the children to go to our schools. So what are you doing for us?”

Shao also blasted the DHS for putting a shelter in “a community of immigrants who often don’t have a voice.”
Ivelisse Torres is a shelter resident who works in retail. “We’re here because they’re against us,” Torres said. “They’re saying we don’t have jobs. Majority of us have jobs, they just don’t want us there.” “They don’t know us, they don’t know what we’ve been through, they just don’t want us there,” Torres added.

Reach Jackie Strawbridge at (718) 357-7400, Ext. 128, or @JNStrawbridge.

3 thoughts on “Protesters Clash Outside Pan Am Hearing

  1. Joe Moretti

    At least the Asians are standing up for what is right in their community. They do not want another homeless shelter (and especially one as large as this)dumped again in their community, especially the way this sneaking situation was handled.

    Certain communities have had to carry this burden, while other do not, so kudos for them for being so organized and coming out in full force. More than would happen in my community of Jamaica.

    And as feeling sorry for the other side, as one who has seen many shelters dumped in my community, I have seen what happens in those areas. Noise, loitering, bad behavior, litter and worse when management allows a what-ever attitude with some of these places. Then property values go down more because who wants to live near one of these places.

    Sorry, until people learn to behave like civilized people and have respect for their community, then these shelter and the people who occupy them will be shunned. They are problematic and there needs to be major oversight and proper management, otherwise these become just another crap hole place for people to act out.

    Why don’t the powers to be who want these places so bad, put them in their own back yard. de Blasio, executives of Samaritan Village, etc. instead of dumping them in already overcrowded areas that are somewhat problematic to begin with. Fix the damn system first before dumping crap like this in communities.

    So to those in homeless shelters, learn manners and respect. And it is not like you wake up one day and are homeless, that is bull. It is a long process that gets you to that point.

  2. Donna Radisch

    With respect to all, my opinion is that these Protesters are propagating Bullying by bringing children to the what should be a peaceful protest. In response to the man who said he is not in China anymore, my question is why did you leave? Why are you trying to deny education,shelter & a possibility employment to get back on their feet? There is a phrase, “There by The Grace of God Go I”. Act and be the inspiration to children, remember everybody meets their maker when their time is up.
    For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in.” Matthew 25:35

  3. Christina

    The fact of the matter is – which the Trib conveniently left out of the story – is that the shelter residents decided to take it upon themselves to start crap at the protest, which was NOT in front of the hotel. They mixed in with the protesters and started harassing them and the police had to separate them out and send them across the street where they continued their “go back to China” and “go make me chicken wings” chants in front of THEIR OWN KIDS.

    1/4 of the people at that shelter are not from NYC, and only 1/4 of them are from Queens. Why is Elmhurst the dumping ground for the whole city as well as a refuge for those from other parts of the country? Because NYC gives away more free crap than anywhere else and we stupid taxpayers allow it. Elmhurst already has a “family shelter” down the street causing all types of problems, so why should the area be expected to take on more?

    Save your bible crap. Jesus never said to allow freeloaders to mooch off society. These folks have more expensive phones and shoes than you do.

Comments are closed.